Introduction
I recently opted to replace my beloved Sony Vaio Z (SVZ) laptop with a new Clevo w230s laptop. While the Vaio Z had served me well, it had a couple of limitations that were really starting to annoy me. Specifically, the Vaio Z was limited to 8 GB and the 256 GB SSD could only be increased by replacing them with an expensive 512 GB Sony proprietary model. Finally the external AMD GPU of the Vaio, while neat in concept, would only work in Linux with the open source driver and performance was atrocious.
Prior to the Vaio Z I had owned a Clevo machine that I purchased from Mythlogic, while not particularly attractive and a bit of a brick, it was powerful, easily upgradeable and user maintainable. This laptop is still going strong and being abused as my 13 year old son’s gaming laptop, it’s durability in this role has been very impressive.
Based on that positive experience, I purchased the Clevo w230ss from Reflex Notebook and the purchase went well with no issues as the laptop showed up at my door approximately four weeks later. I opted to use a Canadian company instead of Mythlogic this time as I wanted to support a Canadian alternative for Clevo/Sager resellers and didn’t feel like driving to Ann Arbor this time for the tax savings. I do highly recommend Mythlogic though, they were an excellent bunch to deal with last time.
Anyways, I thought it would be fun to do a short review of the laptop particularly from a Linux perspective since Linux is my primary OS for day to day work. Please keep in mind that I use Arch Linux which is a rolling release distro in that you are always running the latest and greatest. Thus there is a chance that while some things work fine for me they may not be functional under other distros such as Ubuntu which may have a slightly older kernel.
So with all of that in mind, lets move on to the review.
Appearance
The w230ss laptop has an appearance that could be best described as functional. It’s not a particularly sexy laptop, like a Macbook or my Vaio Z, but it’s not ugly either. The two tone finish of the laptop with silver on the inside and black on the outside is reasonably attractive and fits in well in the corporate environment. In some ways, the w230ss reminds of “sleeper” cars which are the cars when you look at them seem like perfectly ordinary family sedans but hide an enormous amount of power under the hood.
The back of the LCD is a rubberized material which feels nice but attracts skin oil like there is no tomorrow. On the whole though I like the rubberized finish.
Ports
This is the biggest issue with the laptop. While the number of ports are certainly sufficient (3 USB 3.0, 1 USB 2.0, HDMI, VGA, Ethernet) the layout is pretty crap-tastic. The right side of the laptop has the 3 USB 3.0 ports, HDMI, VGA and Ethernet and unfortunately the ports start right at the front which means if you use a mouse and are right handed plugging anything in will interfere with the mouse. The only work around I can see is buying some right angled cables off the net to keep the cables close to the side of the laptop.
The left side has the single USB 2.0 port and once again it is right at the front along with the 1/8” mic and headphone jack. Even if you don’t use the USB port on the left, left handed mouse users will find the left side is no better then the right since the fan vents here. In winter it’s great as your hand gets nice and toasty when gaming, other times not so much.
The one port I wish was included is display port so that high resolution monitors could be used. While HDMI is getting better in this regard it still has limitations at higher resolutions which won’t be addressed until HDMI 2.0 is available.
Keyboard
The keyboard feel is much better then my Vaio Z and is a pleasure to use, one of the better laptop chiclet keyboard that I’ve used over the last few years. As a software developer I am extremely thankful that Clevo designed the keyboard with full size arrow keys, this trend started by Apple towards half size arrow keys on laptops has been driving me insane.
Also, the inclusion of dedicated keys for Home, End, Page Up and Page Down is a welcome sight as I constantly use these keys to navigate code. On most smaller laptops such as my Vaio Z accessing these keys typically involves using the Fn key in combination with the arrow keys which I find quite irritating.
Finally the keyboard has three levels of back-lighting (None, Low, High) and the back-light key works fine under Linux for controlling it. However I don’t see any way to automate the control of the keyboard light as it doesn’t appear to have a device listed under /sys/class/leds, there is a phy0_led but its brightness value doesn’t change.
Trackpad
It works under Linux but since I never use it I can’t speak to the quality of it.
Display
My laptop came with the 1080p FHD display, displays with larger resolutions are available however I would highly recommend checking that your preferred Linux Desktop Environment (DE) supports HiDPI displays well before purchasing one.
The 1080p display on this laptop is nice and bright compared to my Sony Vaio Z. Viewing angles are very good and text is nice and easy to make out. Some users might opt to use scaling but in Gnome I have no issues reading text with scaling off (scaling factor of 1), everything is crisp and sharp. The display is matte, not glossy, and thus has minimum reflectivity even in office environments with overhead fluorescent lighting.
Power Management
I’m using Arch Linux with TLP to provide active power management, I also use bumblebee to disable the Nvidia GPU unless it is needed. TLP does a great job of managing power, with it enabled the screenshot below shows the tunables from Powertop and the ones in the Bad category are not things you typically would want to tune.
Under Arch I get about 5 to 5.5 hours of light use under battery with the screen dimmed to about 75%. The wattage being consumed is 15.5 watts as per powerstat.
Temperature and Fans
There are some complaints on various forums with respect to fan noise for the w230st and to a lesser extent the w230ss. This concerned me as I like my laptop to be as silent as possible when using it for work. I’m please to report though I find them mostly unfounded and have been very happy with the noise profile of this laptop.
When doing basic tasks in my home office, the CPU temperatures are around 45 Celsius and the laptop is dead quiet with the fans never spooling up. At the office when I’m doing coding, running servers, etc the CPU temperatures are between 50 and 60 degrees. In this scenario the fans will spin up lightly every once in a while but I find it to be barely noticeable and not distracting. It’s certainly not the on/off pattern so many people were complaining anout with the w230st.
In terms of gaming, I’ve only tried the Witcher 2 in both Linux and Windows. Unfortunately the Linux port of Witcher 2 is awful and the performance was atrocious so I didn’t bother looking at temps as I quickly moved over to Windows. Under Windows, the CPU temperature is about 80 degrees while the GPU is 71. This is in high settings with Bloom disabled.
When playing the Witcher 2 the fans are running constantly and the volume is correspondingly louder, after all you can’t pack this much power in a small laptop and expect silent fans when gaming. Speaking for myself though, I find the fan noise is drowned out by the game music and effects that I just don’t find it very noticeable. I will say though that if I accidentally place a drink with-in 6 inches of the exhaust fan on the left side it will quickly warm up. I’ve ruined more then one cold drink by doing this.
Dual Booting
As I mentioned in another post, I dual boot between Linux and Windows using rEFInd as the EFI boot manager. No issues with this setup except I had to adjust a Windows registry setting to ensure that time and time zones where treated the same in both OSes as per this blog post here.
One benefit of rEFInd is it will auto-detect any EFI boot loaders on USB sticks making it trivial to boot maintenances tools like an Arch Live USB or Gparted. This is much more convenient then trying to mess with the BIOS boot loader settings. Another benefit is not having to deal with GRUB any longer.
Summary
So in summary this is an excellent alternative for the Linux user looking for a powerful laptop with gaming capabilities.
Did you have any problems after the purchase to now in your daily work?
Are all components except Optimus, are recognized and work properly on Linux?
Thanks for reply
The only issue I have is with the headphone jack not working after resuming from sleep, see my follow-up here (http://gexperts.com/wp/update-on-clevo-w230ss-review/). Otherwise everything works fine including Optimus (with bumblebee).
Hi there, great review. I’m about to pull the trigger but have a couple of questions.
How is the performance of the machine compared to the z1 you moved from? Any issues since you’ve gotten it?
Cheers,
Shane
Performance is excellent, haven’t noticed much difference CPU wise but the GPU is miles better then the ATI/AMD chip included in the Sony’s PMD. No other issues since I’ve gotten it, it’s been nice and reliable so far.
This laptop collects good reviews already for a long time. Currently I am considering buying this model or T440p. Warranty, and docking station is an advantage of lenovo hardware. The disadvantage are problems with installing Linux in UEFI mode.
Yet I wonder which screen size choose:
– FHD
– QHD+ 3200 x 1800 LED, IPS or
– WQHD 2560 x 1440 LED Mat
Currently Clevo is cheaper by 10%. But has better graphics and can be bought without OS.
I’d recommend the FHD screen personally, I just don’t the HiDPI support in most OSes is consistently good enough for the higher res screens. Additionally as a gamer I find the 860m power is perfect match for the FHD resolution.
Can you tell more about battery life? How long it can work in cases like:
Programming?
Gamming?
Movies?
Internet browsing?
So currently I’m taking a 3.5 hour flight twice a week for work. When watching videos it lasts the entire trip with maybe 20% left at the end. I tried Windows gaming on the laptop a couple of times but didn’t time it, somewhere in the 1.5 to 2 hour range when playing Dragon Age Inquisition. Both cases are with screen brightness set to around 60%.
Hello,
Do you mind sharing the hardware and configurations you have?
I have the same laptop with a 4710MQ, 8GB RAM and an 500GB HDD, even using an external display, I get close to 2.5 hours on linux, with tlp installed.
I have the 4810MQ processor, 16 GB of RAM and two SSDs (one with Linux and one with Windows). I’m running Arch Linux as my distribution, what distribution and kernel version are you running?
I’m with Fedora21, gnome-shell 3.14 and the 3.18.3 kernel version
(I couldn’t reply to your comment, I don’t know why)
So you are pretty much at the same level I am, no idea why there is a difference in battery life. Have you tried running powertop to see what is going on?
Yes I have, I see nothing out of the ordinary. I’m running TLP and Tuned. Thanks anyway!
Dumb question, do you have bumblebee installed and is the Nvidia 860m disabled by default? I’m using bumblebee so my 860m is never active unless I’m gaming.
Yes, bumblebee is running and at least bbswitch reports that the gpu is off (/proc/acpi/bbswitch).
First of all, thank you for the great review. I’m considering buying the w230ss and was wondering whether it would run linux (ubuntu/arch) without issues and if the keyboard was good and you answered that in your review.
I also wish DisplayPort was available, in my case for daisy chaining. In any case, have you tried using the laptop with an external monitor using the provided HDMI at 1080p and/or 2560×1440? Did it work without issues?
I’d like to use the laptop with an external monitor and I still haven’t decided on whether to get a 24 inch at 1080p or a larger one, likely 27, with 2560×1440.
I use Arch Linux as my day to day OS and it runs fine on this laptop. The only issue I have found is the one about the headphone jack that I highlighted in a follow-up post, have a look at that for more info. The keyboard is excellent, I’m a coder so that’s my bread and butter. As mentioned in the review, I really like the fact that this laptop has full size arrow keys and distinct Home/End/Page Up and Page Down keys as you don’t typically find this at this size.
I use a 1920 x 1200 external monitor and it works fine, I haven’t tried a 2560 x 1440 monitor but in theory it should work. I’ve debated about getting a 2560 x 1440 monitor but I don’t think the 860m is up to gaming at this resolution and I’m reluctant to downscale.
Finally I’d recommend checking around and seeing if a new version of this laptop will be released soon with a 970m/980m, if so I’d recommend waiting for that.
Thank you for your prompt reply. A new version has been announced but they just mention “nvidia next generation graphics”, the remaining parts seem to be the same. I think I’ll be waiting for the next model to hit the shelves.
Link to W230SD:
http://www.clevo.com.tw/clevo_prodetail.asp?id=779&lang=en
The GPU is actually the same as GTX 860m, 960m is just a GTX 860m, based on the same architecture, just factory overclocked.
Hello, I know how to make the fans a lot more silent. All you have to do is undervolt the processor by -70mV (for i7 at least) and set the clock multiplier for the 4 cores to 30x (i use 25x, works for me stable and so quiet) the only times it’s humming is when the hard drive needs to work. I am using Windows 7 though and the Intel Extreme Tuning Utility. I recommend to try some overclock utility in Linux to do this. Thinking of installing Linux dual-boot with Win 7 myself.
Hi, I have just bought this laptop, and I’m running Manjaro (a variant of arch). It has a 4710MQ processor and the 3200×1800 screen.
My battery life seems fine, but I find that it constantly has a fan on creating a soft hum and a bit of a buzz. I’ve fiddled with some things like lm_sensors, but they don’t seem to recognise the computer’s hardware, and I’m just wondering if I *should* be able to eliminate this buzz during light use.
When you say “dead silent”, do you mean literally dead silent, or simply pretty quiet?
By “buzz” I mean the palm rest vibrates. I probably could have chosen a better word…
By dead silent, I mean dead silent as the fans don’t appear to be running at all when I’m doing browsing or basic word processing. If you run top what processes are you consuming the most CPU? Also, have you installed a power management tool like TLP?